PDA

View Full Version : Conversations with an "ex-gay"


NathanATX
03-08-2006, 01:45 PM
This is from a myspace "ex-gay" group.

David OechsleWrote:
Again, simply because one "feels" like he/she is gay, is attracted to someone of the same gender, does not make this "feeling" a valid feeling. Homosexuality is a behavior. There are people who "feel" like murdering others, molesting children, having sex with animals, eating 3 cheesecakes daily while still standing in the open door of the refrigerator, using cuticle nippers to clip a baby to death, driving into a crowd of white people because they are not muslims, and so many other things. How can you say that ANY of those "feelings" is less valid than the "feeling" of being sexually attracted to another person of the same gender?

We have an instruction manual: the Bible. For those literalists: God never mentioned cuticle nippers in the Bible, so does that make it acceptable to nip a baby to death? How about half to death--just marring his appearance? Is such a thing as that mentioned in the Bible? No, but we know, through the Character of God which He has revealed in His Word, that these things, which aren't literally mentioned in the Bible, are WRONG!

Homosexuality is mentioned as wrong in both the OT and the NT. And, I, too, have been liberated. I don't have to consider what my sexual preferences are.

Nathan Responded:
If I were one to be easily offended, your first paragraph would have done the job. Equating love with murder is absurd. Trivializing sexuality down to a animalistic behavior insults both gay & straight people.

My request is that you would refrain from using such derogatory and inflammatory statements.

And just so you know, there is not a biblical word in either greek or hebrew for homosexuality.

I would assert to you that biblical writers did not have a concept of homosexuality in the context that we understand today, two people forming lifelong loving & committed relationships.

I would also assert that biblical writers who did write about homosexual behavior, wrote about it in the context of promiscuity, temple prostitution, and abandoning God. These are things that have nothing to do with my life or that of MANY gay christians that I know.

And finally, you know the verses that say "As a man thinks in his heart, so is he." My question for many of you is this: You think being gay and or living life as a gay person is wrong. If you know in your heart you are still attracted to people of the same sex, but you're just not acting on it... How does God see you? If your desire for a person of the same sex is sin and you think & fantasize about it... then how does God see you?

Well, let me help you out.

I believe that God sees each and everyone of us with love & compassion. I believe that those of you who are so ashamed & guilt ridden about your sexuality simply break God's heart... with compassion for you, not anger.

Even if homosexuality was sin, which it absolutely is not, the Bible says that nothing can separate us from God. The Bible says that WHOSOEVER calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved. Jesus said to have eternal life we must love the Lord our God with all our heart, soul, mind & strength and love our neighbor as we love ourselves.

That's it.

God loves us. We are perfect and beautiful in His eyes. Just the way He created us.

The only time we miss the mark is when we doubt that love... when we doubt the pure, simple & delightful love that God has for us.

When we're doubting that love, fear comes in. We open the door to living a life outside of the awareness of God's love. And we miss the mark more and more.

The solution isn't trying to be good enough, "straight" enough to get into heaven.

The solution is to realize you already are.

keltic63
03-08-2006, 01:58 PM
YES!!!!!!! Nathan, you have hit on what I've thought about ex-gays and so-called "Side B" christians (gay people who acknowledge their orientation but claim that acting on it [behavior] would be sinful.) I've wondered too about one's thought life in that situation. If a person is attracted to someone of the same sex, then one is still homosexual; acting or not acting on it would be of no consequence because, in this view, it is the state of being gay that is wrong.

Like you, I believe that God has created us as we are; When I started behaving in a way that is "natural" for me, a gay man, I experienced more blessing and a closer relationship to God, not to mention a loving relationship with my partner like I've never had with a woman.

NathanATX
03-08-2006, 02:12 PM
T-dub-yaWrote:
My prayer is that the blindness is removed and your heart is softened. I enjoy reading your posts because you aren't a stupid idiot trying to just simply stir up strife, but you are intelligent in your posts. We should question things, but when we are questioning the very Word of God, that is scary. If homosexuality is so good, then why do most people want out of it? Our very hearts condemn us, but God will give us over to caloused hearts if we don't repent and that is also very scary.

Nathan responded:

Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Tyler. One of this group's main intentions, spoken or not, is to assert that homosexuality is a sin and that homesexuals should change. You hope to draw people in who have been struggling with guilt about their sexuality and provide them with the answers you believe to be truth.

If you truly believe your position to be truth, you really shouldn't feel threatened by dialoguing with me or with others who disagree.

I'm not going to intentionally insult or harass anyone and I expect the same from you all.

Now, you mentioned that it is scary to question the word of God. Why? Religious scholars have been doing it for thousands of years. Denominations form around different answers to that questioning. I believe we should most certainly question and wrestle with the Bible. If we didn't, we would have to apply literal, word-for-word, rules & practices to our lives. And all of you know that we don't do that.

So why do people feel ok to question things like the biblical justification for slavery & segregation that were used in the civil rights movements, but not question the biblical justification for oppressing gay & lesbian people?

Are gay & lesbian people that much easier to hate?

Does christianity require an enemy? ... that's an interesting thought that I'm going to have to chew on...

I do agree, Tyler, that MANY people want to stop being gay or lesbian. Don't you think that there are some pretty clear reasons why?
-rejection from churches & family
-being taught & believing that gay people go to hell
-the fact that is socially acceptable to deride & discriminate against gay people. Ask any gay high school kid.
-not having any role models of successful, happy gay & lesbian people
-not having any role models of annointed gay & lesbian spiritual leaders

As a young man or woman, growing up in church, with a passionate heart for God... loving prayer & worship... feeling called to ministry... constantly giving time to church projects & mission trips... It's pretty heartbreaking to think that all of that could be ripped away from you if you accept your sexuality.

And we question why people struggle with guilt & fear about their sexuality?

The church has inflicted it upon them.

Vanessa White
03-08-2006, 02:13 PM
Thanks, Nate and Keltic. There can be no more natural feeling than to love my partner, and the child we are parenting together, with my full heart and soul, and I did not create that, GOd created that capacity within me. Also, gay whether in mind, body, behavior or spirit, is gay, so if God views acting on gay feelings as wrong, gay feelings/attrractions would also be wrong in the eyes of God. I live my life in such a loving way, that nothing stands in the way between me and my relationship with God. I feel sad for persons that believe so strongly that there is something wrong with us, because it separates those people from loving other people, and I know that God would find that to be wrong. Let us to continue to love ourselves as fully and capable and loving as we are, as God loves us. Peace, :love: :pray:

revtj
03-08-2006, 03:14 PM
I've always wanted to ask the therapists and preachers who support the ex- gay movement this question...

Would you be happy to know your daughter was marrying an ex-gay man?

If they say yes, I would want to point out the miserable statistics of "relapsing" into gaydom. Why put someone you love through that?

If they say no, which I expect all of them would secretly feel, then I would want to know why they don't believe in the teachings of their own religion?