PDA

View Full Version : Gay bashing at Vanderbilt University


TigerXero
09-14-2007, 10:47 PM
I'm a freshman at Vanderbilt University (which is in Nashville, TN), and I just wanted to bring some attention to recent happenings on campus. Last weekend, there was apparently a gay bashing on campus. A graduate student and his boyfriend, who is an alumni of VU, were waiting in line at one of the dining facilities beneath one of the fershman/sophomore student dorms on campus (the Towers to be specific). Two other guys in line started verbally harrasing them, and a bit of a verbal fight broke out. The two guys then left the facility, and the gay couple finished getting their food and eating. Upon leaving the Towers, the gay couple was then assaulted by these two men, who focused on one of the two gay guys (I do not know which one that was). One of the two assailants escaped, but the other one, who is a VU student, was aprehended and jailed. He is being handled by the metro police and being punished by the school as well.

However, here's the thing. There has been no publicity of this event at all. No one knows about it. It has not been talked about in any of the school or local city newspapers. Apparently, the vibe I am getting is that the University does not want people to know about what happened (what would that be like for their reputation if hate crimes were happening on its campus), but we're hoping to help leak the story to someone who will publish it. However, this is not the first time Vanderbilt has apparently been quiet about a hate crime. When I talked about what had happened last weekend in my Women's and Gender Studies class, my professor informed me that last Spring (or the Spring before last) one of her students was attacked for being gay as well (she only found out after she inquired why he had not been coming to class), and he was injured so badly, he couldn't even remember what had happened to him. No one knew about this inicident either, there was no publicity, and the University did not let any outside source (like the metro police) know and handled it themselves. It's a weird similarity between how the situation is being handled now, albeit the fact they are letting the metro police punish one of the attackers.

It is just very concerning for me that awareness is not being raised about this issue, that no one is talking about it. The University talks about other crimes on campus, such as rape, but why not this? The Princeton Review ranks us as one of the bottom twenty gay friendly schools in America. Maybe they have a point.

I'm basically going to rant now about other things that will hopefully be changed on campus in the future, but what I said above was the extent of my posts purpose.

Another issue I've noticed on campus, which the Human Rights Campaign Vanderbilt (HRC) {which just started up this year and is partially led by the Vice Executive of the Vote No on TN #1 campaign} and the Vanderbilt Lambda Association (Lambda) {which has been around since 1988 and is a Gay/Straight Alliance which does a number of different social and educational activites} have pointed out, is that there seems to be no visible LGBT population on campus; I've never seen a same-sex couple holding hands; we need more visibility. Also HRC is interested in pushing for a number of changes. Our 'one room' LGBT resource center is secluded in an obscure area of campus, so we need a much larger facility that is located more centrally on campus. Our campus has a sexual orientation non-discrimination policy, but it does not cover gender identity/expression, and it needs the latter to protect transgender individuals. We don't have a LGBT Alumni Association, and we need one to help raise and sustain funds for our LGBT organizations. HRC wants to make an LGBT studies major/minor and believes that Vanderbilt should have an active interest in recruiting LGBT students to come to their school and have an admissions counselor who will specifically do that; they also believe that there should be the option to mark your sexual orientation on the college admissions application as there is a need for openly LGBT students at Vanderbilt to help bring about change on campus. There also needs to be someone high[er] up in the school's hierarchy to represent us, and as we are looking for a new school Chancellor right now, it is also extremely important that the next Chancellor is progressive and pro-gay and has a record of being so. There are several things that HRC and Lambda want to change concerning the campus atmosphere as well, but it's going to be many, many years before we are able to reach the many goals that these organizations have.

I feel like I've come to Vanderbilt at a very strategic point in time, and I also wanted to rant about the crap going on at our school.

Zerbie
09-14-2007, 10:58 PM
"Come Out and Win," by Sue Hyde of the National Gay & Lesbian Task Force, devotes most of a chapter to suggestions about campus organizing around LGBT issues. Book is published by www.beacon.org

It sounds like the silence is the biggest thing your campus LGBT group wants to combat right now. Who in that organization knows someone on staff at the university's paper? Get the story talked about. Letter to the editor if you can't a feature published.

If this silence is indeed mandated by university higher-ups, and if you have the numbers of motivated students, LGBTs and allies, perhaps a big rally and cross-campus march, demanding that university officials speak out against anti-gay hate crime.

TigerXero
09-14-2007, 11:01 PM
Here, I looked up the Vanderbilt University Police Department records of the incident online.



9/9/2007
23:15


Simple Assault


2401 West End Ave (Carmichael Towers)


Victim was assaulted otuside Carmichael Towers by two suspects, believed to be students.

Subject was issued a state citation.



I feel that given what happened that this police report is a bit lacking in information, namely the fact that it was a hate crime, but is such an attack even able to be prosecuted as such in Tennessee? I don't know.

Daniel
09-15-2007, 09:48 AM
Zero,

I found this resource.

http://rainbowlaw.org/html/directoryTN.htm

Sounds like you have an article on your hands, especially if there is a pattern of violence.

Zerbie has a great suggestion. A letter to the school's paper could start things going.

Here's something to think about. You're a freshman, right? How about getting in touch with HRC/Lambda and getting the ball rolling? You have 4 years to make a difference. Find other people at your school who will join with you in change.

Think big. Start small.

You can make a difference.

Steven E. Webster
09-15-2007, 01:00 PM
Friends,

The victim of this assault may be in some shock, and may not be willing to come forward and be further "outed." Unfortunately, many victims of anti-LGBT assault on college campuses simply drop out and are never heard from again.

I saw from one of the articles Daniel linked to that there is a hate crimes law in Tennesee that should cover this case. If the victim of the assault was selected for assault because of their sexual orientation, then the police are not correct to charge the perpetrators with "simple assault."

Is Vanderbilt trying to sweep all this under the rug? Or do they have any pro-active programs addressing either the reality or the potential of anti-LGBT assault and harrassment on campus? Do LGBT students on the Vanderbilt campus feel safe? If not, why aren't they making a stink about it? LGBT students are entitled to feel safe on the campus!

Steven Webster

TigerXero
09-15-2007, 04:06 PM
Friends,

The victim of this assault may be in some shock, and may not be willing to come forward and be further "outed." Unfortunately, many victims of anti-LGBT assault on college campuses simply drop out and are never heard from again.


This is what the President of Lambda was saying. That the last thing on their minds is getting media coverage of the event, although this was because they were recovering from the incident, not because they didn't want to be outed.

TigerXero
09-16-2007, 12:05 AM
Since I didn't have any inside information, I've been posted the information above, but I just received a very comforting e-mail from the President of Lambda, and everything is being taken care of. I'll post it below:

> Jody,
>
> I appreciate your concern about all of this. However, I am unable to
> give that information over email. Let's just say that you are welcome to
> talk to me in person about it sometime as I am fully aware of the answer
> to your question and exactly what is being done, but currently, I am fully > obligated to not release any details surrounding your question.
>
> About your other emails: Concerning the other "crime" that occurred, I
> have a feeling that I know what incident you're talking about. I will be
> asking Jared [HRC leader] about it just to make sure, but if it's the incident that
> I'm thinking of, it wasn't technically a hate crime. At least, it could
> never be proven as such and there was a lot of circumstantial evidence
> surrounding it. The situation involved much more than homophobia and
> was very serious in terms of student privacy.
>
> Also, a press release was given from the administration to the Hustler [school newspaper]
> yesterday, and news about it will be appearing in the Hustler next week.
> In fact, as early as this morning I was contacted for an interview. Of
> course, this will naturally result in further spreading of this incident
> to the metropolitan media. Keep in mind that this incident is being
> handled exactly the way it should. I, honestly, could not ask for better
> results at this time. Mark Bandas has completely turned his office
> around in terms of handling biased crimes on this campus. Evidence of
> this includes his immediate address of hate emails (of which I get at
> least two a week as president of Lambda). He is going to institute a
> series of consequences that will pretty much guarantee that these stop
> (i.e. electronically tracing the sender, which could not be done
> before). Also, I think the fact that Dean Bandas and Chancellor Zeppos
> are coming to the Lambda meeting on Thursday is a very clear indication
> of the level to which the administration is acting on this matter. I
> know you haven't been here long, but these two individuals coming to a
> regular student organization meeting is absolutely unheard of,
> especially at a Lambda meeting. He is also mandating mandatory Safe Zone
> training and a complete revision of VUPD procedure and policy. Also,
> student government is revamping so as to increase awareness of this
> incident and improve upon its legislation to consider GLBT students more
> closely.
>
> You may think that this situation was not handled quickly enough, but
> indeed it was. Of course, the university administration must internally
> organize their statements and actions before any further steps can be
> taken. Naturally, it takes time to do this in order to ensure that the
> most effective steps are taken. Even in terms of the prosecution of the
> individual who committed this crime, I can assure you that the best
> steps are being taken. Remember, a certain amount of pushing can be too
> much pushing. You must maintain a certain composure and diplomatic
> consciousness in order to most effectively get your message across.
>
> On that note, it is not necessary for you to write anything. Soon,
> everyone will be fully aware of what happened: I guarantee it. As soon
> as the incident occurred, the GLBT office was notified and university
> policy immediately went into action. Just because the general public was
> not made aware to begin with does not mean that the administration was
> not doing everything in its power to resolve the situation. One of the
> victims is a good friend of mine, and even he is very happy with how it
> is being handled. Furthermore, no one can be more concerned about this
> incident than I am, and the fact that I am content with the
> administration’s proceedings is a very positive sign (considering that
> we do not live in a perfect world). Again, press releases are going
> everywhere over the weekend. The best thing you can do is remain
> concerned but allow the administration to finish what it has already
> started. I can assure you that policies are being revised even as we
> speak, and the campus will be much better for it.
>
> I’m sorry that I can’t communicate with you about your initial question
> – in writing – but I am fully bound to confidentiality. For now, I wish
> to make it quite plain that, although your concern is legitimate, it
> works out for the best on several levels and will absolutely not result
> in any less publicity or any less punishment for the attacker. In
> addition, it will probably result in even more policy revisions. As far
> as these incidents being internally swept under the rug, it is quite
> clear that no longer is the case. The incident that you cited in your
> email – again, if it is the same one I’m thinking of, which I’m pretty
> sure it is – is another case altogether, and there is a fine line
> between that incident and this one. As far as that case goes, I can
> absolutely not say anything more about.
>
> Oh yeah, PS I just looked up the police report link you sent me, and
> that is not the most up to date document, and it only includes a mere
> summary of the events. I have seen the official press release and the
> actual metro report. I’m sure you would find those much more satisfying.
>
> In short (well I guess this turned out to be quite long), I truly
> appreciate your concern, and I can see that you are going to be a very
> positive force on this campus. But, rest assured that the proper steps
> are being taken. It never hurts to give the system a chance to act
> properly and revise its procedures --- never be too quick to act. If
> you want to talk more about your other questions, I would be happy to
> take some time for that. Anyway, have a good rest of the weekend, and I
> hope to see you Thursday.
>
> -Klint.


So... everything's being handled fine. That's good to know. I was just in the dark about it. Sorry for all the unneeded concern (and anger). ^_^;;...

Steven E. Webster
09-16-2007, 05:25 PM
As your campus LGBT leader promised--here's the published report of this incident:

http://www.insidevandy.com/drupal/node/4756

I think it's very cool that care is taken not to identify the victims. I think part of the dynamic that leads to students in this kind of situation dropping out of school is feeling that they aren't safe on campus anymore. Having their names published might make them feel less safe.

I suffered an assault once--by a police officer in an anti-Viet Nam War campus protest. (I wasn't doing anything wrong and I wasn't arrested--I was just in the wrong place at the wrong time and got clubbed.) It was a very traumatic experience--it put me in some emotional turmoil for months. I was 20 years old, and before that very emotional year ended, I came out to myself as a gay man. I still sometimes joke that it was that clubbing that "turned me queer."

Steven Webster

Robert
10-23-2007, 06:24 PM
I graduated from Vandy. It was many years ago but I feel for you.
When I was there I would never have said a word about being gay.
I still wonder how many guys I knew secretly were. Of course most
of them are married now because those were the rules.
I loved Vandy but the students where all so much alike---very little diversity of any kind. I guess that hasn't changed. Good luck with your efforts. You have your work cut out for you.

TigerXero
10-28-2007, 07:43 PM
Actually, I'd have to disagree on the diversity part. I know economically, the diversity on campus has exploded in the last few years concerning the economic situation of students who are accepted. I believe this change came about because of the work Chancellor Gee (who has just left the University) brought about. Also, I know there is a great deal of diversity (at least compared to the school I came from) here relating to ethinicity. For example, I went to a Diwali (a Hindu festival) theatre play a few days ago, but this was only possible because of the large Masala-SACE (literally "rice" - South Asian Student... um...something) on campus. Also, the school does not feel as preppy as its reputation usually makes it out to be. That's apparently a change that has coincided with the economic diversification.

As far as LGBT issues are concerned, I know there is a lot of support here on campus, although it could be so much greater, and I'm sure there are people who are hiding, but there also a lot of people who don't hide the fact that they are GLBT. Oh, and do you remember McGill Hall? Apparently it's known as the liberal/alternative lifestyles dorm. Was it known as that when you were here?