You'll find a lot of people in that boat. I was born a Methodist and then transplanted to the Church of Christ. Michigan can be a hard place, because there are so many small towns and conservatives. The city of Lansing, where I go to school, is pretty accepting and there is an abundance of resources to serve the needs of the LGBT community, including Open and Affirming churches. Back home in Frankfort, there's nothing really, the Gay-friendly church is 45 minutes away, and is a UU church, so for non-Unitarian gay folk it gets hard to live a full spiritual life.
Man will never be truly free until the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest.