Home > Forums

Go Back   Soulforce Community Forums > Community Center > Faith and Nonviolence

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 10-09-2007, 08:16 PM
AJLove AJLove is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 140
Default Men and Violence (Please Revise)School Project I have to do.

Men's Passion for Violence




For centuries violence has played an enduring role in the upbringing of human history. From the American Revolution to the Iraqian War,mankind has always struggled inside the "warbox". As Judith Butler said in Issue 2 of The Believer Magazine, "Peace is a resistance to the terrible satisfactions of war." However we all know these events are due because of the hunger for power between men. Whether it's trying to be the best basketball player or the greatest dictator there ever was. Men has never ceased to hold back their greed for authoruity and power over others.Why is this so? Can this be stopped?You masy ask. Well I ask you this: Is it possible to stop something that seems to be almost like an animalistic instinct or a natural emotion? Will all men eventually come to an understanding,resulting to maybe peace on Earth ? These are the questions of Men's Passion for Violence.


Why is it so?

Dominance and power are often the keys of survival in the animal world. It is alomost required for a male to show his competence over other males and show them who's "boss."In most cases this causes a challenge where as the two males conflict in a duel to prove who's best .Notice anything familiar? Even though we may seem to be superior than the other animals of the animal kingdom,we are suprisingly very similar. In the human world these things happen all the time,between classmates in school,siblings in your own home,and even your fellow co-workers at your own workplace. Day-to-day violence between men has grown to such intensity that we often find ourselves resenting each other for the wrong reasons. In some cases it is the fear of something or someone that causes these spiteful emotions to arise.For example, homosexuality betweem men is more contemned then women, because of the fear that this "unatural" phenomenom is something often potrayed as evil, sinful, immoral, or ummanly-like. Why? Well,because many people have expectations of what a "real" man is suppose to be: Real men are strong. Real men fear nothing or no one.Real men love and are attracted to only women. Real men show no mercy or any sign of grieful emotion.Thus, causing violence in where gays are killed or are verbally and physically abused everyday because of men that feare of becoming something that is not often valued. as manly. In other situations these type of things happen because some men find it hard to let a gay male call himself a man. However, as I mentioned before men's passion for competitiveness often resorts to violence aswell.Where as a man must prove that he is worthy of maintaining his title as a "real man". So as you can see fear and the edacity for dominance are only some of the main contributors of violence.


Can this this be stopped?

As a human baby it is only natural for you to eventually stand upright and learn to walk. But also as a child it is natural for you to resort to violence by crying ,screaming or sometimes having tantrums, when you do not get your way.Now think about a time where you unwilliingly became violent . Therefore, if it is natural for you to be violent,then how can you end something that is not taught, but is already exist deep in your consious at birth? However, the level of violence a person contributes to,is often taught to them or they have picked it up and learned it from past experiences. So if a man is taught to hate those "inferior" to him,what do you think the outcome would be? For something such as violence to be already in your state of mind at birth, then elavated when you are being taught to resent others,it seems impossible to stop. Thus,my answer to this question is no. Violence will be everlasting,unless men no longer contribute to it.


Is or will there be a such thing as peace on Earth?

I'm sure you've heard of the term Peace on Earth. My question to you is, will it ever exist? As I mentioned before men are the main contributors to violence. Therefore if men dont come to an understanding with each other there will be not peace.Thus,tieng in with the previous question :Can this be stopped?".If violence is not stopped ther ewill of course be no peace. For the generations to come men will always find a reason to began a war or to hate something or someone. It is virtually our destiny as humans to be destructive upon this dieing world. It will take a miracle for men and mankind to learn that violence solves nothing,but makes room for more vehemence.

Men will always be destructive. It is a price that we all have to pay. Even though it is natural, it can sometimes be controlled.However,not everyone is willing to be taken advantage of. Men are the reason for war. Men are the reason this world is coming to a slow end. In the future somethings will not change. Some things will get better,while others get worse.It is all in the hands or men and mankind to decide the fate of our future,by no longer enduring violence, But is it the passion of it that keeps me coming back for more.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 10-09-2007, 08:29 PM
Zerbie's Avatar
Zerbie Zerbie is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Phoenix
Posts: 5,470
Default

Good start.

What do you mean by "please revise?" Are you looking for editing on the grammar, spelling, and style? Or comments on the content?

You need to proof read this - I assume it's a first draft - spelling, grammar, and style issues.

The content is good, but it needs clarification in many places. The best part of your essay, imo, is the part where you state that violence will not stop unless all people make the effort to resist unnecessary violence. Very true.

I kept wondering why you said "men" and not "human beings." I kept wondering if you were making the case that this is a gender issue - something relevant to males more than to females. I cannot tell if when you write men, you are singling out the male gender (an idea supported by the fact that you cite the behavior of male animals) or speaking about a generic human tendency. If you are treating this as a gendered issue, simply say so in the first paragraph of your essay.
__________________
***
Never linger too long with the ignorant,
throw stones at their talk.
Walk only with the lovers,
the mirror of the soul gets rusty when
dipped in muddy water.


-Rumi
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 10-09-2007, 08:34 PM
scrupulous_stoic's Avatar
scrupulous_stoic scrupulous_stoic is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Near Palm Springs
Posts: 216
Default

Here you go!

For centuries violence has played an enduring role in the upbringing of human history. From the days of early civilization in Mesopotamia to the War in Iraq (I changed this to be more broad, rather than focus on American history), mankind has always struggled inside the "warbox". As Judith Butler said in Issue 2 of The Believer Magazine, "Peace is a resistance to the terrible satisfactions of war." However, we all know these events are incited from the hunger of power amongst men. Whether it's trying to be the best basketball player or the greatest dictator there ever was, competition for greatness has been an ever-present component to the human psyche. Men have never ceased to hold back their greed for authority and power over others. Why is this so? Can this be prevented, you masy ask? Well, I pose this question to you: Is it possible to stop something that seems to be almost like an animalistic instinct or a natural emotion? Will all men eventually come to an understanding,resulting to maybe peace on Earth? These are the questions concerning mens' passion for violence.


Why is it so?

Dominance and power are often the keys of survival in the animal world. It is alomost required for a male to show his competence over other males and show them who's "boss." In most cases, this causes a challenge where as the two males conflict in a duel to prove who's best. Notice anything similarities, anything familiar? Even though we may seem to be superior than the other animals of the animal kingdom, we are suprisingly very similar. In the human world, these things happen all the time, between classmates in school,siblings in your own home, and even your fellow co-workers at your own workplace. Day-to-day violence between men has grown to such intensity that we often find ourselves resenting each other for the wrong reasons. In some cases it is the fear of something or someone that causes these spiteful emotions to arise. For example, homosexuality between men is more condemned than same-sex relations between women, because of the fear that this "unatural" phenomenom is something often potrayed as evil, sinful, immoral, or effeminate. Why? Well, because many people have expectations of what a "real" man is suppose to be, stereotypes that have echoed in patriartical societies such as ours: Real men are strong. Real men fear nothing or no one. Real men love and are attracted to only women. Real men show no mercy or any sign of grieving emotion. Thus, Much violence and abuse, whether it be verbally or physically, is directed towards gays from men whose mindsets are only set to tolerate the masculinity that men are supposed to uphold according to society's standards. In other situations, these type of things happen because some men find it hard to let a gay male call himself a man. However, as I mentioned before, mens' passion for competitiveness often resort to violence as well.Where as a man must prove that he is worthy of maintaining his title as a "real man". So as you can see fear and the edacity for dominance are only some of the main contributors of violence.


Can this this be stopped?

As a human baby, it is only natural for you to eventually stand upright and learn to walk. But also as a child, it is natural for you to resort to violence by crying ,screaming or sometimes having tantrums when you do not get your way. Now think about a time where you unwilliingly became violent. Therefore, if it is natural for you to be violent,then how can you end something that is not taught, but is already exist deep in your conscience at birth? However, the level of violence a person contributes is often taught to them or they have picked it up and learned it from past experiences. So if a man is taught to hate those "inferior" to him,what do you think the outcome would be? For something such as violence to be already in your state of mind at birth, then elavated when you are being taught to resent others,it seems impossible to stop. Thus,my answer to this question is no. Violence will be everlasting, unless men no longer contribute to it.


Is or will there be a such thing as peace on Earth?

I'm sure you've heard of the phrase "Peace on Earth." My question to you is this: will it ever exist? As I mentioned before, men are the main contributors to violence. Therefore, if men dont come to an understanding with each other, there will be no peace. Thus, invoking the previous question: Can this be stopped?. If violence is not stopped there will be no peace whatsoever. For the generations to come, men will always find a reason to begin a war or to hate something or someone. It is our destiny as humans to be destructive upon this dying world. It will take a miracle for men and mankind to learn that violence solves nothing, but makes room for more belligerence.

Men will always be destructive. It is a price that we all have to pay. Even though it is natural, it can sometimes be controlled. However,not everyone is willing to be taken advantage of. Men are the reason for war. Men are the reason this world is coming to a slow end. In the future somethings will not change. Some things will get better, while others get worse. It is all in the hands of men and mankind to decide the fate of our future, by no longer enduring violence. But is it the passion of it that keeps me coming back for more.
__________________
gnothi seauton

-Delphic Maxim-
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 10-09-2007, 08:35 PM
scrupulous_stoic's Avatar
scrupulous_stoic scrupulous_stoic is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Near Palm Springs
Posts: 216
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Zerbie View Post
Good start.

What do you mean by "please revise?" Are you looking for editing on the grammar, spelling, and style? Or comments on the content?

You need to proof read this - I assume it's a first draft - spelling, grammar, and style issues.

The content is good, but it needs clarification in many places. The best part of your essay, imo, is the part where you state that violence will not stop unless all people make the effort to resist unnecessary violence. Very true.

I kept wondering why you said "men" and not "human beings." I kept wondering if you were making the case that this is a gender issue - something relevant to males more than to females. I cannot tell if when you write men, you are singling out the male gender (an idea supported by the fact that you cite the behavior of male animals) or speaking about a generic human tendency. If you are treating this as a gendered issue, simply say so in the first paragraph of your essay.
I agree. The exclusiveness of the word "men," rather than "humanity," threw me off.
__________________
gnothi seauton

-Delphic Maxim-
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 10-09-2007, 08:37 PM
AJLove AJLove is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 140
Default

Well my report was on the relation between men and violence.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 10-09-2007, 08:47 PM
Progo35 Progo35 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: MA-either N. Andover (home) or Wenham (school)
Posts: 646
Default

AJLove:

There is a fantastic book on male violence called The Dark Side of Man, by Michael Ghiglarelli. It is all about men's genetic predisposition to violence and agression. I highly recommend that you look into it. You can order it from Amazon at this link:

http://www.amazon.com/Dark-Side-Man-.../dp/0738203157
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 10-10-2007, 09:05 PM
Joe Brummer Joe Brummer is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: New England
Posts: 448
Default

There is a film by Adam Katz called "tough guise" about men and boys and violence. I am not sure you can just download it, but I bet you could get a copy at the library.

It covers some great stuff including the media and violence with men.
How GI Joe has "grown" since his start.
How guns in movies and tc have grown.) look at Bogarts Derranger compared to Rambo's or Arnolds machine guns)

It is a great movie and valuable for a student.

Peace,
joe

Last edited by Joe Brummer; 10-10-2007 at 09:17 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 10-12-2007, 02:27 PM
scott snedeker's Avatar
scott snedeker scott snedeker is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Fort Pierce, Florida, Any Forest, Short Mountain
Posts: 1,394
Default first proof

below is my first proof. I had to stop but I will finish

Quote:
Originally Posted by AJLove View Post
Men's Passion for Violence




For centuries violence has played an enduring role in the upbringing of human history. From the American Revolution to the Iraqian War,[]mankind has always struggled inside the "warbox". As Judith Butler said in Issue 2 of The Believer Magazine,: "Peace is a resistance to the terrible satisfactions of war."
pp
However we all know these events are due because of the hunger for power between men. Whether it's trying to be the best basketball player or the greatest dictator there ever was. Men has[have] never ceased to hold back their greed for authoruity and power over others.[][]
pp
Why is this so? Can this be stopped?You masy ask. Well, I ask you this: Is it possible to stop something that seems to be almost like an animalistic instinct or a natural emotion? Will all men eventually come to an understanding,resulting to maybe peace on Earth ? These are the questions ofthat explore] Men's Passion for Violence.


Why is it so?

Dominance and power are often the keys of survival in the animal world. It is alomost required for a male to show his competence over other males and show them who's "boss."[][]In most cases this causes a challenge where as the two males conflict in a duel to prove who's best .[][]Notice anything familiar? Even though we may seem to be superior than the other animals of the animal kingdom,[]we are suprisingly very similar.
pp
In the human world these things happen all the time,[]between classmates in school,[]siblings in your own home,[]and even your fellow co-workers at your own workplace. Day-to-day violence between men has grown to such intensity that we often find ourselves resenting each other for the wrong reasons. In some cases it is the fear of something or someone that causes these spiteful emotions to arise.[][]For example, homosexuality betweem men is more contemnedmore intensely condemned thenthan between women, because of the fear that this "unatural" phenomenom is something often potrayed as evil, sinful, immoral, or ummanly[-like].
pp
Why? Well,because many people have expectations of what a "real" man is suppose to be: Real men are strong. Real men fear nothing or no one.[]Real men love and are attracted to only women. Real men show no mercy or any sign of regretgrieful not a word emotion, thus, causing violence in where gays are killed or are verbally and physically abused everyday because of men that feare of becoming something that is not often valued. as manly.
pp
In other situations these type of things happen because some men find it hard to let a gay male call himself a man. However, as I mentioned before men's passion for competitiveness often resorts to violence as[]well.[]Where as a man must prove that he is worthy of maintaining his title as a "real man". So as you can see fear and the audacityedacity [wrong word] propensity would work better for dominance are only some of the main contributors of violence.


Can this this be stopped?

As a human baby it is only natural for you to eventually stand upright and learn to walk. But also as a child it is natural for you to resort to violence by crying ,[]screaming or sometimes having tantrums, w. When you do not get your way.
pp
Now think about a time where you unwilliingly became violent??????? . Therefore, if it is natural for you to be violent,[]then how can you end something that is not taught, but is already exist deep in your conscious at birth? However, the level of violence a person contributes to,[]is often taught to them or they have picked it up and learned it from past experiences. So if a man is taught to hate those "inferior" to him,[]what do you think the outcome would be? For something such as violence to be already in your state of mind at birth, then elavated when you are being taught to resent others,[]it seemswould seem impossible to stop. Thus,my answer to this question is no. Violence will be everlasting,unless men no longer contribute to it. Previous paragraph needs to be completely rewritten using four sentences


Is or will there be a such thing as peace on Earth?

I'm sure you've heard of the term Peace on Earth. My question to you is, will it ever exist? As I mentioned before men are the main contributors to violence. Therefore if men dont come to an understanding with each other there will be not peace.Thus,tieng in with the previous question :Can this be stopped?".If violence is not stopped ther ewill of course be no peace. For the generations to come men will always find a reason to began a war or to hate something or someone. It is virtually our destiny as humans to be destructive upon this dieing world. It will take a miracle for men and mankind to learn that violence solves nothing,but makes room for more vehemence.

Men will always be destructive. It is a price that we all have to pay. Even though it is natural, it can sometimes be controlled.However,not everyone is willing to be taken advantage of. Men are the reason for war. Men are the reason this world is coming to a slow end. In the future somethings will not change. Some things will get better,while others get worse.It is all in the hands or men and mankind to decide the fate of our future,by no longer enduring violence, But is it the passion of it that keeps me coming back for more.
__________________
Love and affirmation,


Forrester Tongpa Nyi (formerly Ash Phoenix, faeries evolve! )

When you come to know that your entitlement to joy is a given, All that remains is the exploration of the many different ways to let it in
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:22 AM.


The views expressed in the Soulforce Community Forums are the views of the individual authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Soulforce.
©Copyright 2008 Soulforce, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Web Development by Curious Find.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.